David Nicholson Reserve Straight Bourbon
Staff Pick

David Nicholson Reserve Straight Bourbon

Item # 38653 750mL

This old 19th Century St. Louis brand was a local favorite for years, known for its generous flavor profile and complexity that was still easy drinking enough for any occasion.

$34.96/ Single Bottle
$209.76/ Case of 6
Enter a delivery zip code
Check Availability
Free shipping on first web orders over $299
available for pickup by noon Tomorrow Pick-up this item at our shop!
This item is featured in a tasting on: tasting date
This item is featured in: WineClub
This item is featured in AstorCenterClass at Astor Center
Need Help Deciding? Get personal recommendations from our staff

Staff Pick Notes

Looking for Buffalo Trace? Try this instead. Same price, higher proof, and absolutely full of flavor. What about this bourbon do I find appealing...I like that David Nicholson Reserve holds up on the rocks and is denser than many (of my beloved) bottom-shelf bourbons. The mash bill is rye weighted but taste-wise remains solidly in bourbon territory. For an everyday American classic to sip after work or keep in your decanter, give this whiskey a whirl.

- SS

Sign up. Get 10% Off.

Get a promo code for 10% off when you sign up for our emails.


Offer available to new subscribers. Cannot be combined with any other offers. Does not apply to items on sale, solid cases, corporate orders, or orders containing an item priced at more than $10,000.